An authority marketing agency can deliver a positioning brief, original material based on your expertise, a plan to put that work in front of buyers, and a report on what happened. Which of those you’re buying depends on the proposal. An introduction to a journalist, a published interview, and an advertisement are three different purchases.
Imagine you run an architecture studio. Prospective clients keep asking whether to renovate in phases or close a building for the entire project. You can explain the trade-off in a meeting, but your buyers have no way to hear that explanation before they call. That is a specific problem an agency can help solve. Ask each bidder what it would leave behind for the next buyer who asks.
Start with the question your buyer needs answered
In George Wright III’s episode on authority before marketing, he argues that wider distribution amplifies whatever positioning a business already has. For the studio, that suggests a useful test: could the agency name a buyer, a decision, and an example from your practice before it proposes a posting schedule?
If you’re still deciding whether this approach fits the business, start with how authority marketing works. If you’re comparing proposals, ask for the scope in terms you could check on delivery day.
Four handoffs to look for in the proposal
- 1. A brief you can correct
- Ask for a sample that identifies the audience, the buying question, the founder’s point of view, and the evidence available. A slide that calls you a “trusted expert” leaves the writer guessing. A brief that names the studio’s phasing decision gives you something to edit.
- 2. An asset you can put to work
- Specify the format, source material, reviewer, and final files. For the studio, that might mean an interview with the principal turned into an illustrated decision guide. Ask who verifies technical claims and obtains permission to show project photos before publication.
- 3. A record of distribution
- Separate what the agency publishes on your channels from what it submits to someone else. For outreach, request a list of relevant outlets, the angle sent, and the status. For a paid placement, ask where it will appear and which costs are outside the fee.
- 4. A report that changes the next decision
- Ask to see a sample with a starting point, a reporting period, and an interpretation. If visitors read the guide but never reach its worksheet, what would the agency investigate? A list of impressions alone gives you little basis for choosing the next assignment.
These are possible handoffs, not a standard package. A specialist who only conducts interviews and writes may be the right choice if your team already handles publishing and measurement. Price the work that still falls to you, including the founder’s time and the editor who has to get the piece over the line.
PROPOSAL FIELD GUIDE
Who controls the promise?
- 01 AGENCY
A draft arrives
The team can produce it.
Specify the file, deadline and review criteria. - 02 PUBLISHER
An editor says yes
An outside party decides.
Separate a pitch sent from a placement secured. - 03 BUYER
A reader responds
The audience chooses.
Define the signal and how you’ll observe it.
Put two offers through the same test
Consider two fictional proposals for the architecture studio. One offers an article series and media outreach. The other offers one interview, a buyer’s guide on the studio’s site, and editable diagrams. A count of deliverables favors the first. The studio’s actual sales conversations might favor the second.
WORKED EXAMPLE · HYPOTHETICAL
The acceptance test
Give both agencies the same assignment: “A facilities director asks whether to renovate in phases. Show me what I can send her when our engagement ends.”
For the article series, ask to see the proposed installment that answers that question, who hosts it, and what happens if no editor accepts the pitch. For the guide, ask to see a sample diagram, who supplies the underlying project details, and whether your team can update it when conditions change.
If the studio needs independent editorial exposure, outreach may be worth buying. Judge the research and pitch quality separately from acceptance. If the sales team urgently needs a resource it can send tomorrow, ask for the first usable version and its delivery date. Both bids can be sensible; they solve different problems.
If a proposal includes search visibility, Google’s guidance on hiring an SEO recommends asking for previous work and says nobody can guarantee first place. Request examples and a description of the work behind the forecast. Treat a ranking target as a target.
Decide what a useful first report would show
AMEC’s communications evaluation framework distinguishes outputs from audience responses, outcomes and impact. Apply that distinction to the guide. Publishing it is an output. A facilities director downloading the worksheet is an observable action. A later project award is a business result with other possible causes.
Agree on what you can observe before the work starts. Record where comparable inquiries come from today, how your team identifies a qualified inquiry, and who will ask buyers what they read. If the studio has no baseline, say so in the first report. A buyer mentioning the diagram on a call is useful evidence; it does not establish that the diagram won the project.
At handoff, open the files using your own account. Locate the approved copy, image permissions, editable source, published URL, and reporting instructions. Ask a teammate to change one caption in a draft. That small exercise can reveal a dependency a line about “asset ownership” would never show.
ASK BEFORE YOU SIGN
“For the first piece we commission, what will I receive, what do you need from me, who can approve it, what can my team reuse, and what evidence will we review together?”
Send the same question to every bidder. A reply specific enough to put in the scope is more useful than another portfolio slide.

